Between Howard Zinns work and the Patriots work, I believe the more accurate one is Howard Zinn. The patriots portray America as the best country with no flaws. They let the corruption and other flaws of America slide because we are suppose to maintain this perfect look of America. With Howard Zinn, he tells everything from the side of the people. Since they didn’t have a voice, Zinn decided to take that into his own hands. He tells his readers of the struggles of the people and what they wanted from the government, the president, and so forth. That makes Zinn more accurate because he is doing something that not many historians do. He gives us a different way to look at history. After reading these two competing histories, I’ve learned that history can be told in different ways or even viewed in different ways. Some people believe that America is the all mighty while others think that it sucks. It just shows different perspectives people see.
Howard Zinns work raises issues about the purpose and significance of studying history because he actually tells us about the situations. He not only gives us the information, facts, and dates, he gives us the feelings of the people. He compares past events to present events like when he talked about the holocaust being almost no different then slavery. He gives his opinions within his writing too, like when he says that America isn’t all about freedom like they say. The benefits to this method is that the people who read his work can actually understand what was happening during the event. He also explains his side so well that it’s a clear picture for the audience to see. The drawbacks to this method is that most historians aren’t seen as people who explicitly tell what they believe, and Zinn does. That might cause some people to not want to read his books. I believe he is right about America during word war II and the Cold War. We didn’t do anything to help the people outside our nation. We also were no different then those nations because we allowed imperialism and racism to still happen from past to present.
During the 1920′s and 1930s, America had chosen an isolationist government. We were still paying the costs for previous wars and didn’t have time nor the money to get involved with another one. If they kept a distance from the works then they’d be okay! They were still trying to get better from the great depression and trying to make America better! This led to the involvement of ww2 however because even though we tried to stay out, our allies (Britain) was running out of supply and weapons. Of course America helped and it showed they were helping in the war.